SEO has dozens of signals, and most lists treat them as equal. They aren't. This checklist puts twelve checks in order of impact, starting with whether Google can find and index your pages at all. Each one names the free tool that verifies it and how often to look again. The last section lists old advice you can drop in 2026.
The checklist at a glance
Work top to bottom. A problem near the top can hide every win below it: a page Google can't index gets no benefit from a better title.
| Check | Verify it with (free) | Re-check |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Important pages are indexed | Search Console, Page indexing report | Weekly |
| 2. robots.txt doesn't block important sections | Search Console → Settings → robots.txt | After every deploy |
| 3. No accidental noindex | URL Inspection in Search Console | After every deploy |
| 4. One canonical URL per page | URL Inspection, "Google-selected canonical" | Monthly |
| 5. Live pages return 200, not 404 or 5xx | Search Console, Page indexing report | Weekly |
| 6. Redirects go straight to the final URL | A site crawler | Monthly |
| 7. HTTPS everywhere, no mixed content | Chrome DevTools → Console | After every deploy |
| 8. Sitemap lists your canonical URLs | Search Console, Sitemaps report | Monthly |
| 9. Unique title and meta description | A site crawler | Monthly |
| 10. Link text describes the target | Read your anchors out of context | When you publish |
| 11. Meaningful images have alt text | A site crawler | When you publish |
| 12. Core Web Vitals are good | Search Console, Core Web Vitals report | Monthly |
Can Google find and index your pages?
Checks 1 to 5 decide whether a page is in the running at all. Start in the Page indexing report and look at why pages are not indexed, not just how many.
- robots.txt controls crawling, not indexing. Google says it "is not a mechanism for keeping a web page out of Google" (Google robots.txt guide). To keep a page out, use
noindex. - A stray noindex is the classic silent failure after a redesign or a plugin update. If a page you want in Google carries one, see how to find and remove a noindex tag.
- Canonicals tell Google which URL is the main one when several show the same content. Google's starter guide advises that each piece of content is reachable through one URL; a missing canonical tag leaves the choice to Google.
- Status codes matter because only working pages can rank. Pages returning errors waste crawling and break the links that point to them.
If Search Console shows Crawled - currently not indexed for pages you care about, our guide to that status walks through what to do.
Is the site technically clean?
Checks 6 to 8 are plumbing. Visitors never see them, but crawlers trip over them.
Each extra hop in a redirect chain adds a round trip before the page loads, so point every redirect at the final URL. Serve every page over HTTPS, and fix any mixed content, where an HTTPS page loads a script or image over plain HTTP.
Keep your sitemap to the canonical URLs you want indexed. Google uses lastmod only when it is consistently and verifiably accurate, so update it only when the page really changes (Google sitemap docs).
Do your pages earn the click?
Checks 9 to 11 shape how you appear in results. Google's starter guide says a good title is "unique to the page, clear and concise, and accurately describes the contents of the page" (SEO starter guide).
Snippets come mostly from your page text, sometimes from the meta description. Write a short, unique description for each important page, and make your opening paragraph answer the page's main question.
Link text tells people and Google what the target page is about. "See our pricing" works; "click here" doesn't. Alt text should explain how an image relates to the content around it, in a short phrase.
Are your Core Web Vitals good?
Check 12 is speed, measured on real users. The "good" thresholds, at the 75th percentile of page loads, are below (web.dev Core Web Vitals).
| Metric | Measures | Good |
|---|---|---|
| Largest Contentful Paint (LCP) | Loading | 2.5 s or less |
| Interaction to Next Paint (INP) | Responsiveness | 200 ms or less |
| Cumulative Layout Shift (CLS) | Visual stability | 0.1 or less |
Google says it "highly recommends" good Core Web Vitals and that they align with what its ranking systems reward (Google Core Web Vitals docs). Google doesn't say how much they count, so fix them, but don't expect speed alone to lift a page that fails checks 1 to 11. If your lab score jumps between runs, read why Lighthouse scores change before chasing it.
What can you drop in 2026?
Some checklist items no longer earn anything. Skip these and spend the time above.
| Old advice | What Google says now |
|---|---|
| Add FAQ markup for rich results | FAQ rich results stopped showing in Google Search in 2026 |
Tune sitemap priority and changefreq | "Google ignores" both values |
| Fix heading order for rankings | "it doesn't matter if you're using them out of order" for Search; keep it logical for screen readers |
| Add special files or markup for AI Overviews | A page only needs to be indexed and eligible for a snippet; "There are no additional technical requirements" |
Sources: Search Central updates, the sitemap docs, the starter guide and AI features in Search.
Keep the checklist running
One pass catches today's problems. Sites change with every deploy, CMS update and new script, and any of them can bring back an issue you already fixed.
UpCrawler crawls your whole site on a schedule, from weekly on the Free plan to every 6 hours on Pro. It reports issues by severity with the affected pages, and alerts you to robots.txt problems, sitemap issues and new critical issues. See what the crawler checks.
Want this list run on your own site? Run a free audit and check your homepage in about a minute.
Share it with whoever runs your site’s SEO.

