Alternate page with proper canonical tag: ignore it or act

Search Console lists some pages as alternates with a proper canonical tag. Usually that is healthy. Here is how to spot the few cases that need a fix.

Published

Three grey URL rows joined by green lines to one green box with a check mark
In short

Seeing "Alternate page with proper canonical tag" in Search Console looks alarming, but it is usually good news. Google found a variant of a page, saw a canonical tag pointing to the main version, and indexed that main version instead. Google's own help says there is nothing you need to do. Act only when the canonical points to the wrong page.

What the status means

A canonical URL is the one version of a page you want Google to show in search. A canonical tag is the line in the page's HTML that names it.

Google's Page indexing report help describes this status in one sentence: "This page correctly points to the canonical page, which is indexed, so there is nothing you need to do." It sits among the not indexed reasons, which is why it looks like a problem. The page that matters, the canonical, is in the index.

Why these alternate pages exist

Most sites create variants of the same page without anyone noticing. Google's canonicalization overview and its guide to consolidating duplicate URLs cover the usual sources:

  • URLs with tracking parameters, such as ?gclid=ABCD added by ads
  • AMP versions of articles
  • mobile and desktop versions of a page on separate URLs
  • HTTP and HTTPS versions of the same page

If the count rises after you start an ad campaign or a newsletter with tagged links, that is expected. Each tagged URL is one more alternate pointing home.

Alternate, duplicate or overridden: which status you have

Search Console has three canonical statuses that sound alike but mean different things. The table shows which one asks for work.

StatusWhat happenedGoogle's viewWhat to do
Alternate page with proper canonical tagYou named a canonical and Google agreed"nothing you need to do"Nothing, unless the canonical target is the wrong page
Duplicate without user-selected canonicalYou named no canonical, so Google picked one"not an error"Add a canonical tag if Google picked the wrong page
Duplicate, Google chose different canonical than userYou named a canonical and Google picked anotherGoogle calls it an errorInspect the URL and remove the conflicting signals

Google calls a canonical tag "a strong signal", not a command. Redirects are a strong signal too, and sitemaps a weak one, and Google says the signals stack. So when your tag, your redirects and your internal links all name the same URL, you see the first status. When they disagree, you drift toward the third.

When the status hides a real problem

The status itself is never the bug. The bug is a canonical tag that points somewhere you didn't intend. Look for these patterns:

  • A page you want in search is on the list. A product, service or blog post listed as an alternate is telling Google to rank a different URL.
  • Every page points to the homepage. A theme or plugin that prints one fixed canonical turns your whole site into alternates of /. Google's canonicalization troubleshooting guide warns that a CMS or plugin "can make incorrect use of canonicalization techniques".
  • Page 2 and beyond point to page 1. Google's pagination guide says plainly not to use the first page as the canonical. Give each page a canonical pointing to itself.
  • The canonical points to another domain. Google notes that attackers sometimes add a cross-domain canonical to a hacked site.

A page that prints two different canonical tags confuses the signal in the same way. See multiple canonical tags for how that happens and how to remove the extra one.

How to check a listed URL

You can triage the list in a few minutes with tools you already have.

  1. Open the Page indexing report and click the "Alternate page with proper canonical tag" row to see example URLs.
  2. Scan for pages you want in search. Parameter URLs, AMP and mobile variants are fine and can be skipped.
  3. Paste any surprising URL into the URL Inspection bar at the top of Search Console. It must belong to the property you have open.
  4. Compare "User-declared canonical" with "Google-selected canonical". Both should name the page you want indexed. If both name another page, your own tag is sending Google there.
  5. Open the page in your browser, view its source and search for rel="canonical". Check that it doesn't redirect elsewhere.

A correct tag on the main page names itself, with the full HTTPS URL:

html
<link rel="canonical" href="https://example.com/blue-widget">

Fixing a wrong canonical by platform

Where the tag comes from depends on how your site is built. Fix it at the source, not page by page.

WordPress

The canonical usually comes from your SEO plugin. Check the per-page canonical field first, then the plugin's global settings. If no plugin is installed, WordPress core prints its own canonical on single posts and pages.

Shopify

Themes print the tag from the canonical_url object in theme.liquid, as Shopify's theme SEO guide shows. If a theme edit or app replaced it with a fixed URL, restore {{ canonical_url }}.

Next.js

With the App Router, set the canonical in the page's metadata. Relative paths need metadataBase set in the root layout.

ts
export const metadata = {
  alternates: { canonical: '/blog/my-post' },
};

After the fix, use the "Validate fix" button only if the report lists a real issue. For healthy alternates, there is nothing to validate.

Found this useful?

Share it with whoever runs your site’s SEO.

Ready when you are!Crawly, the UpCrawler mascot

Catch the next drop on day one.

UpCrawler watches your uptime, crawls every page and tracks Search Console, so you see the turn the day it happens.

14 days freeNo cardNothing to install